Friday, December 17, 2021

Hastings—Lennox and Addington (Ontario) 126/338

 Hastings—Lennox and Addington (Ontario)


Today we're in Hastings—Lennox and Addington!


Hastings—Lennox and Addington has existed as a riding since the 2012 redistribution, created from Lanark—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington and Prince Edward—Hastings. The population of the riding was 94,333 in 2016. The population centers are Loyalist (16,971 in 2016), Napanee (7,439 in 2016), and Belleville (50,716 in 2016, shared with Bay of Quinte).

Politically, this seat has been historically Conservative. When the Liberals have won a majority in modern history, they win this seat. Even though they didn't win the seat, they were very close in 1980, just 1,079 votes separating the Liberals from the PC's. Most recently, Mike Bossio narrowly won the seat by just 225 votes. This seat is currently held by Conservative MP Shelby Kramp-Neuman.

The MP before Shelby Kramp-Neuman was Derek Sloan. Derek Sloan won this seat in 2019 with just 41.4% of the vote. After winning his seat, Sloan ran for the Conservative leadership in 2020, getting fourth place and 15.64% of the vote. Sloan was expelled from Conservative caucus in 2021 and sat as an independent until 2021. He ran in Banff—Airdrie in the 2021 federal election, taking just 2.6% of the vote. In 2019, this seat was 14/121 in Ontario and 42/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 5.7/10 - All the names make sense, but the name is far too long.
Shape: 4.1/10 - Again, it makes sense, but I can't forgive how ugly it is.
Individuality: 3.8/10 - It's not uncommon for rural Ontario seats to be majority bellwethers.
Total: 13.6/30 (45.3%)

We'll be on a break until January, happy holidays, we'll be back with Hochelaga in 2022!

Thursday, December 16, 2021

Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas (Ontario) 125/338

Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas (Ontario)

Today we're finishing off our Hamilton adventure with Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas!


Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas has existed as a riding since the 2012 redistribution. The population of the riding was 113,024 in 2016. The riding contains the neighbourhoods of Ancaster, Dundas, and Meadowvale. Both Ancaster and Dundas were amalgamated into the city of Hamilton in 2001, along with Flamborough, Glambrook, and Stoney Creek.

Politically, this seat has been a Liberal/Conservative seat. It was held by the PC's from 1972-1993 when the Liberals won all but one seat in the province. It only elected Liberals until 2006 when it went Conservative for David Sweet. Most recently it flipped to the Liberals in 2015 and have stayed there since, with relatively no opposition. The seat is currently held by Liberal MP and Minister of Public Services and Procurement Filomena Tassi.

Filomena Tassi first ran for office in the 1995 Ontario provincial election, finishing less than 700 votes behind incumbent MPP David Christopherson. She won this seat in 2015, swinging the seat almost 23 points in her direction. She was appointed Deputy Government Whip in 2017, later getting appointed to be minister of seniors in 2018 and minister of labour in 2019. Most recently, she was appointed minister of public services and procurement in the newest cabinet. In 2019, this seat was 79/121 in Ontario and 190/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 5.2/10 - All the names are relevant, but Ancaster—Dundas would suffice. Name is too long.
Shape: 6.5/10 - Generally good, not a huge fan of having urban Hamilton attached to suburban Ancaster and Dundas.
Individuality: 4.7/10 - Not very individual, ministers are always cool though.
Total: 16.4/30 (54.7%)

Tomorrow we're in Hastings—Lennox and Addington!

 

Tuesday, December 14, 2021

Hamilton Mountain (Ontario) 124/338

 Hamilton Mountain (Ontario)

Today we're in Hamilton Mountain!



Hamilton Mountain has existed as a riding since 1968. The population of the riding was 104,877 in 2016. The riding contains the neighbourhoods of Rolston, Lawfield, and Hill Park. The riding has the highest percentage of visible minorities in the Hamilton ridings, at 23%, however, the minority groups are very split, with Black Hamiltonians being the most represented at just 4.4%.

Politically, this seat has been a close race since 2004, with the main three parties above 20% in all but one election when the Liberals fell to 16% in 2011. Despite it's competitive nature, it tends to stay with one party for some time: the Liberals held it from 1988-2006 and the NDP held it from 2006-2021, with the Liberals winning the seat in the 2021 election. This seat is currently held by Liberal MP Lisa Hepfner.

Marion Dewar held this seat for just over a year, losing in the 1988 general election by just 73 votes.  Dewar was the mayor of Ottawa from 1978-1985, becoming the second female mayor of the city. She tried to return to parliament in 1993 by running in Ottawa Centre, however, despite her local notoriety she lost to Liberal Mac Herb. Her son, Paul Dewar went on to represent Ottawa Centre federally from 2006-2015. In 2019, this seat was 17/121 in Ontario and 55/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 8.2/10 - I like it, the region is notably higher and it is a name that people use for the area, I just wish it was an official name.
Shape: 6.1/10 - Again, not awful, just not a huge fan of the appendage on the left.
Individuality: 8.1/10 - Really cool incumbents and interesting flipping, pretty typical voting pattern for a working class riding.
Total: 22.4/30 (74.7%)

Tomorrow we're finishing off our Hamilton adventure in Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas!

Monday, December 13, 2021

Hamilton East—Stoney Creek (Ontario) 123/338

 Hamilton East—Stoney Creek (Ontario) 


Today we're in Hamilton East—Stoney Creek!


Hamilton East—Stoney Creek has existed as a riding since 2004, created from Hamilton East and Stoney Creek. The population of the riding was 107,848 in 2016. The riding contains the former city of Stoney Creek, as well as the neighbourhoods of Kentley and Grayside. Stoney Creek was amalgamated into the city of Hamilton in 2001.

Politically, this seat has typically been a Liberal seat, held by Liberals from 1962-2006. The party was only ever in trouble of losing the seat in 1980 and 1984, but the opposition has always been split between the NDP in Hamilton and the Conservatives in Stoney Creek. The NDP narrowly took the seat in 2006, holding it until 2015 when former mayor of Hamilton Bob Bratina took the seat back. This seat is currently held by Liberal MP Chad Collins.

Sheila Copps held the seat from 1984-2004. Copps served as the sixth Deputy Prime Minister, as well as holding the cabinet portfolios of Minister of Environment and Minister of Canadian Heritage. She briefly resigned in 1996, keeping good on her promise that she would resign if the government wasn't able to abolish the GST. She lost the nomination in the new Hamilton East—Stoney Creek when fellow MP Tony Valeri argued that because most of his constituents lived in the new riding that she was contesting. In 2019, this seat was 34/121 in Ontario and 95/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 9.5/10 - I really enjoy the name! (I would be okay with just Stoney Creek).
Shape: 8.2/10 - Generally good, I wish it wasn't as long.
Individuality: 6.7/10 - Typical Hamilton seat, but really cool incumbents!
Total: 24.4/30 (81.3%)

See you tomorrow in Hamilton Mountain!

Sunday, December 12, 2021

Hamilton Centre (Ontario) 122/338

 Hamilton Centre (Ontario)

Today we start our Hamilton adventure in Hamilton Centre!


Hamilton Centre has existed as a riding since 2004. The population of the riding was 100,103 in 2016. The riding contains the neighbourhoods of Strathcona, Beasley, and Gibson. The riding has the smallest population of the Hamilton ridings, losing 1,829 people between censuses. One factor is the lakeshore, which is heavily industrial with little to no residential housing.

Politically, this seat has been an NDP stronghold since 2004. Federally, the NDP hadn't historically been super strong here, but they have a base here provincially, winning at least one seat here in all but three elections since 1934. In 1988, the Liberals won this seat from the PC's, a seat they hadn't won since 1965, a sign of regrowth and a good election to come in five years. This seat is currently held by NDP MP Matthew Green.

Speaking of provincial politics, I'd be remiss if I didn't discuss Andrea Horwath. She actually first ran for this seat federally in 1997, losing pretty hard against incumbent Liberal Stan Keyes. In 2004, she won a by-election here, swinging the seat over 34 points in her favour. She has been leader of the Ontario NDP since 2009, increasing their popular vote performance in each subsequent election, leading up to the Ontario NDP forming the official opposition in 2018 for the first time since 1987. In 2019, this seat was 68/121 in Ontario and 164/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 10/10 - I have no notes.
Shape: 9.2/10 - Good non-offensive shape, not a huge fan of the sharp corner on the northeast.
Individuality: 5.4/10 - It would be nice if there was some variety and not just parking with one party for a few years.
Total: 24.6/30 (82%)

Tomorrow we're in Hamilton East—Stoney Creek!


Friday, December 10, 2021

Halifax West (Nova Scotia) 121/338

 Halifax West (Nova Scotia)


Today we're in Halifax West!


Halifax West has existed as a riding since 1979, created from Halifax—East Hants. The population of the riding was 96,255 in 2016. The riding contains the communities of Bedford, Fairview, and Rockingham. The riding has grown 10% between censuses, particularly in the Bedford area, and has become the most populated riding in the province, just ahead of Halifax.

Politically, this seat has been Liberal since 2000, but hasn't necessarily been safe. In 1997, it went NDP with the other Halifax seats, but former MP Geoff Regan took it back in 2000, only really being in danger of losing the seat in 2000 and 2011. The NDP were in second from 2000-2008, but the Conservatives took second from 2011-2019, but the NDP took second place back in 2021. The seat is currently represented by Liberal MP Lena Diab.

The previous MP Geoff Regan held the seat for 24 years non-consecutively. He was a parliamentary secretary under Chrétien, becoming Minister of Fisheries under Paul Martin in 2003, staying the portfolio until the Liberals lost power. He was elected Speaker of the House of Commons in 2015, the first Speaker from the Atlantic since 1922. In 2019, this seat was 11/11 in Nova Scotia and 257/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 8.3/10 - Pretty good, a little lazy, wish there was some reference to Bedford.
Shape: 7.8/10 - I guess the rural parts made sense when the riding had less people.
Individuality: 4.1/10 - Pretty typical urban Atlantic seat, Speaker of the House helps.
Total: 20.2/30 (67.3%)

Tomorrow we start our Hamilton adventure in Hamilton Centre!


Tuesday, December 7, 2021

Halifax (Nova Scotia) 120/338

 Halifax (Nova Scotia)


Today we're in Halifax!


Halifax has existed as a riding since Confederation, one of the few ridings left with this distinction. The population of the riding was 94,610 in 2016. The riding contains the neighbourhoods of Convoy Place, Spryfield, and Armdale. The riding also contains Sable Island, which is located 300 kilometers southeast of Halifax.

Politically, this seat was a Liberal/Progressive Conservative seat from Confederation until 1997. In 1997, NDP leader and former leader of the Nova Scotia NDP Alexa McDonough won the seat, along with their best performance in the Atlantic. Megan Leslie held it after McDonough, until she lost it to Liberal Andy Fillmore. The seat is currently held by Liberal MP Andy Fillmore.

Before 1997, the NDP hadn't had too much success in the Atlantic, they first won a seat here in 1940, on Cape Breton Island. In 1997, they won 8/32 seats in the Atlantic, the closest they've come to since is 2011, when they won 6/32 seats, winning both St. John's seats and 3/4 Halifax seats. In the most recent election, the party didn't win any seats in the Atlantic provinces. In 2019, this seat was 5/11 in Nova Scotia and 116/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 9.2/10 - Pretty much perfect, but Halifax is larger than just this riding.
Shape: 8.1/10 - Also pretty good, I'd prefer if the seat was a bit more urban, instead of this weird divide.
Individuality: 6.8/10 - Interesting how it flipped so easily in 1997 and has been close since.
Total: 24.1/30 (80.3%)

See you soon in Halifax West!


Monday, December 6, 2021

Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock (Ontario) 119/338

 Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock (Ontario)


Today we're in Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock!


Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock has existed as a riding since 1968, originally named Victoria—Haliburton. The population of the riding was 113,956 in 2016. The population centers are Lindsay (20,713 in 2016), Bobcaygeon (3,525 in 2016), and Beaverton (2,822 in 2016). The riding is largely rural, especially in the Haliburton County portion.

Politically, this seat has been one of the safest Conservative seats in Ontario, being Conservative for all but eleven of the past fifty three years. Those eleven years were during the Chrétien years when the Liberals held all but a handful of Ontario seats. After the Conservative party merged, the riding has gotten progressively more Conservative, save the 2015 election where the Conservatives were knocked down to a 44.8% victory. This seat is currently represented by Conservative MP Jamie Schmale.

Completely unrelated to this riding, today (December 6th) is the anniversary of the fourteen young women murdered on the campus of Polytechnique Montréal. Today we remember their futures that were stolen from them. December 6th in Canada marks the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women. In 2019, this seat was 89/121 in Ontario and 217/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 4.8/10 - I get it, the name makes sense, but it is much too long. Haliburton—Kawartha will suffice.
Shape: 3.9/10 - It's giving pre-2012 Durham (that isn't a good thing).
Individuality: 4.1/10 - Not too individual, the former MP was a minister, but it is pretty inline with rural Canada and eastern Ontario.
Total: 12.8/30 (42.7%)

Tomorrow we're in Nova Scotia with Halifax!


Sunday, December 5, 2021

Haldimand—Norfolk (Ontario) 118/338

 Haldimand—Norfolk (Ontario) 

Today we're in Haldimand—Norfolk!


Haldimand—Norfolk has existed as a riding since 1979, getting redrawn and renamed from 1997-2004. The population was 109,652 in 2016. The population centers are Simcoe (13,922 in 2016), Caledonia (9,674 in 2016), and Port Dover (6,161 in 2016). The riding contains Haldimand and Norfolk counties.

Politically, this riding has remained pretty stagnant since 2004. The last time the riding was close was in 2015, when the Liberals were 7.55% behind the Conservatives. In 2008, the Conservatives only received 40.8%, largely due to Gary McHale running as an independent candidate and getting 10% of the vote. This seat is currently held by Conservative MP Leslyn Lewis.

Leslyn Lewis was first elected into parliament in 2021, taking the open seat from Diane Finley. In 2020, Lewis garnered national attention after running for the Conservative leadership, finishing third, winning the popular vote on the second ballot. Lewis actually ran in the 2015 election, running in Scarborough—Rouge Park, getting 27% of the vote. In 2019, this seat was 86/121 in Ontario and 209/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 9.8/10 - I do wish that the entirety of both counties were in the riding.
Shape: 8.2/10 - Again, counties are great, but the little appendages are gross.
Individuality: 4.2/10 - On par with most of rural southern Ontario, the Leslyn Lewis factor definitely helps.
Total: 22.2/30 (74%)

Tomorrow we're north in Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock!


Wednesday, December 1, 2021

Guelph (Ontario) 117/338

 Guelph (Ontario) 


Today we're in Guelph!


Guelph has existed as a riding since 1979. The population of the riding was 131,794 in 2016. The riding contains the entire city of Guelph and follows the exact same municipal boundaries as Guelph. This is one of the few ridings in Canada with this characteristic, Ajax being another off the top of my head.

Politically, this seat has been held by the Liberals since 1993, but the opposition parties have moved around quite a bit. In 1997, the PC's were in second, which matched the neighbouring Halton region. In 2008, the four main parties were within 16 points of each other, with the Liberals winning with just 32% of the vote. In 2019, the Greens surged into second place, taking 25% of the vote. This seat is currently represented by Liberal MP Lloyd Longfield.

Provincially, this seat is represented by Green Party Leader Mike Schreiner. Leader since 2009, he has led the party into three general elections, finally winning his seat in Guelph in 2018 with 45% of the vote. The party has made some gains in recent years, winning 8% of the popular vote in 2007, the year before the federal Greens got the same amount in the province. In 2019, this seat was 55/121 in Ontario and 137/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 10/10 - It speaks for itself.
Shape: 9.7/10 - The issue I have is how overpopulated it is, other than that the riding is a 10.
Individuality: 8.9/10 - We love ridings that bounce around, especially under the surface.
Total: 28.6/30 (95.3%)

Tomorrow we're in Haldimand—Norfolk!




Grande Prairie–Mackenzie (Alberta) 116/338

 Grande Prairie–Mackenzie (Alberta) 

Today we're in northern Alberta with Grande Prairie–Mackenzie!


Grande Prairie–Mackenzie has existed as a riding since the 2012 redistribution, created from Peace River. The population of the riding was 117,327 in 2016. The population centers are Grande Prairie (63,166 in 2016), High Level (3,159 in 2016), and Sexsmith (2,620 in 2016). Driving through the entire riding north to south is impossible, there is no way to pass over the portion of Peace River in this riding.

Politically, this seat has been solidly Conservative since 1958, being held by the also conservative Social Credit Party before that. Being rural Alberta, this seat has had two things happen (almost) consistently in the 21st century: Conservatives above 55% support and no other candidate above 20%. An independent candidate by the name of Bill Given received 20% in 2006. That candidate was city councilor and future mayor of Grand Prairie Bill Given. The seat is currently held by Conservative MP Chris Warkentin.

I believe I've discussed the Socreds before, but that was in a Quebec context. The Socreds contested their first federal election in 1935, winning all but two seats in Alberta at the time. This election happened the same year the Alberta Socreds won their first of nine elections, winning all but seven seats in the Alberta legislature. In 2019, this seat was 31/34 in Alberta and 335/338 in Canada by margin.

Rating:
Name: 9.2/10 - I like they acknowledge the urban center as well as the remote stretches of the riding. Some acknowledgement of the Peace Region would be nice.
Shape: 6.8/10 - I understand the purpose of Mackenzie County being included, it just makes for an awkward shape.
Individuality: 2.8/10 - Bill Given getting local notoriety is cool, but it is very rural Alberta.
Total: 18.8/30 (62.7%)

See you soon in Guelph!


Northumberland–Peterborough South (Ontario) 208/338

Northumberland–Peterborough South (Ontario) Today we're back in Ontario with Northumberland–Peterborough South! Northumberland–Peterboro...